The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

The Best Christmas Rentals In New York You Must Visit

The best rentals in New York for Christmas

Looking for a great place to stay in New York for Christmas? Here are the best Christmas rentals in New York you must visit!

Have a holly jolly season using this guide to navigate the best places to stay in New York for Xmas.

The Big Apple might lose some points in coziness because of its massive size and population, but it totally makes up for it in Instagrammability and its holiday markets during Xmas. And who wouldn’t want to take a horse-drawn carriage ride through Central Park during the winter, when the city is decorated with millions of holiday lights?

You can check out our other round-ups of the coolest places to stay in Los AngelesMiami, and the rest of The United States, too!

I earn a small commission when you book through these links 

Treehouse on the Genesee River

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

This one-of-a-kind beautiful treehouse provides a unique experience. A pull-down ladder gives you access to the sleeping loft with a private balcony and large windows to a gorgeous view of the woods and field. A firepit and a grill are available.

BOOK HERE

Steps to Iconic NYC Attractions!

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

This unique Manhattan property offers sleek and modern design, along with amenities that offer guests a contemporary experience with an incomparable front-row seat at Times Square. You’ll be in the middle of it all, with access to everything!

BOOK HERE

A Beautiful Log Cabin Overlooking Keuka Lake

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Nestled in the hills above Keuka Lake, “A Beautiful Place” is a 1,100 square foot, all-season Log Cabin. This fully furnished cabin sleeps up to 8 guests and is located on six acres overlooking the lake just two miles from the rural village of Penn Yan, NY. Sunrises over Keuka Lake are really special, so “A Beautiful Place” is great for a romantic weekend getaway for two. It’s also perfect lodging for a wine tasting or ski trip, or a fun Christmas family vacation!

BOOK HERE

Huge 1000 sq. Ft. Floor Through Apartment

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

This one-bedroom apartment located on 50th Street & 2nd Avenue offers modern living amenities within a lively neighborhood encompassing some of the most famous attractions and skyscrapers in the world! For your convenience and enjoyment, this home also comes equipped with a private laundry washer-and-dryer and Jacuzzi. The elegantly furnished unit has hardwood floors, fresh greenery, and contemporary accessories.

BOOK HERE

Hudson Valley Getaway Cottage

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

This sun-filled 2 bedroom house is situated on over 3 acres of open fields which provide sublime vistas of the surrounding protected farmland and forest. Enjoy the amazing sunsets as you relax on the large deck overlooking a meadow and meandering creek.

BOOK HERE

Modern Glass Home with Mountain Views

The best Airbnbs in New York

Enthrall your senses in an unforgettable stay at this Cragsmoor glass home! Truly an architect’s dream, this 3-bed vacation rental estate seamlessly blends the indoors and outdoors with floor-to-ceiling windows found in every single room. There’s just the right amount of comfort between you and the Catskill Mountain Range as you shower next to imposing rock formations and seemingly slumber beneath the night sky’s stars.

BOOK HERE

Relaxing Cayuga Lake House

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Beautiful three-bedroom single-family home located in the Town of Ithaca. Private lot with private dock and private swimming and grass area down by the lake. There are also two kayaks, a canoe, and a fire pit on the property.

BOOK HERE

Spacious Hampton’s Beach House

The best Airbnbs in New York

The house is perched on a hill in East Hampton, with convenient access to East Hampton Village, the ocean, and bay beaches. The garden, lawn, pool, and decks are surrounded by a park-like setting and provide a joyful getaway with immense privacy.

BOOK HERE

Pristine Cabin Site on Oswegatchie River

The best Airbnbs in New York

Relax and enjoy yourself sitting on the porches or the new large deck overlooking the pristine ‘Oswegatchie River. The deck has been furnished with a dining table for four along with deep-seated sofas and a propane fire pit. Go swimming, rock hopping, and have a cool beverage while soaking in the many pools in the Oswegatchie River.

BOOK HERE

Lake View Rustic Cabin

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Cozy & peaceful one-room cabin overlooking Keuka Lake. Walking distance to Hammondsport. Located on Finger Lakes Wine Trail / Brew Trail. Clean and set up for couples. Off the Grid Glamping at its finest!

BOOK HERE

Sonder at One Platt | Studio Apartment

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Set yourself up for success at One Platt. A top choice for a remarkable New York stay. Each space features chic decor, a fully equipped kitchen, and access to the state-of-the-art fitness center. Looking for that iconic New York City skyline? The seasonal rooftop overlooks the city and Brooklyn Bridge.

BOOK HERE

Easy to Wander All Over Manhattan!

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

If you’re looking for value and comfort in the Big Apple, look no further than this budget-friendly property. Minutes from popular attractions, the property features convenient amenities such as free Wi-Fi, a fitness center, and an on-site restaurant and bar. Enjoy all the comforts of home in the heart of all the action!

BOOK HERE

Decorators Dream Pied-a-Terre

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Elegant and charming jewel-box apartment on the Upper East Side (prime UES) with mural walls and chandeliers in every room, and coated silk wallpaper in the bedroom.

BOOK HERE

Lovely Duplex Loft in the South Street Seaport

The best Airbnbs in New York

Located on historic Front St, on a charming cobblestone street with views of the Brooklyn Bridge, this elegant, light-filled loft is on a stylish residential block of bustling cafes and cozy neighborhood restaurants. The neighborhood is only a short walk to the chic restaurants and bars of Tribeca, the boutiques and small designer shops of Soho, as well as Chinatown, Little Italy, Noho, and the bohemian haunts of the East and West Village.

Beautiful & Peaceful Lake George Waterfront

The best Airbnbs in New York

Simply put, Lake George is one of the most beautiful and pristine lakes in the country. The northern end is perhaps the most peaceful and picturesque area of the entire lake. This lakehouse is uniquely located facing south on the peninsula of Black Point. Just sit back in a chair on the lawn (or in the living room) with your beverage of choice and watch the wildlife, boats, and movement of the water or wait for the sunset over the mountains.

BOOK HERE

Elegantly Furnished Apartment

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Midtown East, Manhattan is a must-visit community for all first-time visitors to New York City. This one-bedroom apartment vacation rental on 50th Street & 2nd Avenue offers modern living amenities within a lively neighborhood encompassing some of the most famous attractions and skyscrapers in the world! The home is elegantly furnished with hardwood floors, faux greenery, and contemporary accessories.

BOOK HERE

Elegant Triplex With Private Roof Terrace and Empire State Views

The best Airbnbs in New York

Elegant triplex condo with a large private roof terrace with direct access from the unit. Being a recent addition to the top of an existing 19th-century brownstone in Chelsea, this home combines the best of historic charm and modern architecture.

Intimate Midtown Neighborhood Property

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

Welcome to this quiet Midtown escape near iconic NYC attractions! Enjoy complimentary coffee and tea in the lobby, as well as Wi-Fi, a fitness center, and pet-friendly accommodations. Make this your convenient home away from home in the Big Apple!

BOOK HERE

Studio Apartment Just Off Park Ave

The best Airbnbs in New York

Gorgeous and well-designed loft studio apartment located just steps from Central Park and Transportation. The unit accommodates 2 guests with the possibility of a third guest on the sofa bed.

BOOK HERE

Perfect NYC Location! Midtown Manhattan Room

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York

In the exciting Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood just east of the Hudson River and a mere eight-minute walk from Times Square, this hotel offers a one-of-a-kind design features and easy access to many of the famous NYC landmarks.

It’s just a little over a mile from Rockefeller Center and within walking distance of a number of tantalizing restaurants, entertaining bars and nightlife spots, and lively outdoor areas.

BOOK HERE

Cozy and Clean Suite in Chelsea

The best Airbnbs in New York

West Chelsea is a vibrant area of Manhattan, full of dining, shopping, nightlife, art galleries, and studios. Many of its side streets are quaint, tree-lined, and safe to walk.

BOOK HERE

Lakefront Cabin with stunning views in Piseco, NY

best airbnbs in New York City

Known as Camp Stardust, this cabin with massive windows provides jaw-dropping views of Piseco Lake, native wildlife, and of course, twinkling stars. The cabin is all windows, so the views are stunning, even at night. You can turn off the lights, turn on the fire, and enjoy the reflection of the moon of the lake. There are 2 bedrooms, one with a queen-size bed, one with a double, a separate TV room for watching movies, reading, or enjoying that mid-afternoon nap. Plus there are no neighbors, you share this slice of heaven with wildlife and an occasional canoe gliding by.

BOOK HERE

THINK THESE ARE THE BEST CHRISTMAS RENTALS IN NEW YORK? PIN THIS POST TO SAVE IT FOR LATER

The Best Christmas Rentals in New York